Current track

Title

Artist

Current show

Non-Stop HMR!

06:00 19:00


‘In this House, I’m in charge’: Speaker forced to intervene as Starmer presses Johnson in feisty PMQs

Written by on 17/11/2021

Sir Keir Starmer pressed Boris Johnson on the ongoing sleaze scandal in a heated PMQs, calling the prime minister “a coward, not a leader”.

The Labour leader urged the PM to “do the decent thing and just say sorry for trying to give light to corruption” in the wake of the lobbying row which reared its head following the case of Owen Paterson.

Mr Paterson, who resigned as an MP earlier this month, was found to have breached lobbying rules in an “egregious” manner.

Boris Johnson
Image: Boris Johnson was also asked about the eastern leg of HS2 at PMQs

“Here’s the difference, when somebody in my party misbehaves, I kick them out. When somebody in his party misbehaves, he tries to get them off the hook,” Sir Keir told the Commons.

“I lead, he covers up.”

At the end of an ill-tempered session of PMQs, Conservative MP Michael Fabricant raised a point of order on Sir Keir’s use of the word “coward” and asked him to withdraw his comment.

Live updates from PMQs and the PM’s Liaison Committee grilling

More on Boris Johnson

Sir Keir replied: “I withdraw it, but he is no leader.”

Earlier in his questioning of the prime minister, the Labour leader said: “Weeks, weeks defending corruption. Yesterday, a screeching last-minute U-turn to avoid defeat on Labour’s plan to ban MPs from dodgy second contracts.

“But waving one white flag won’t be enough to restore trust, and there are plenty more opposition days to come, and we will not let the prime minister water down the proposals or pretend that it is job done.”

Sir Keir Starmer
Image: Sir Keir Starmer said Mr Johnson is ‘not a leader’

Responding to Sir Keir, the prime minister attempted to question the Labour leader about any links with legal firm Mishcon de Reya.

The PM did not apologise for the affair surrounding Mr Paterson, but repeated it was a “mistake” to conflate the issue with reforming the standards process more generally.

“Well, yes, as I’ve said before it certainly was a mistake to conflate the case of an individual member – no matter how sad – with the point of principle at stake, and we do need a cross-party approach on an appeals process,” the PM said.

“We also need a cross-party approach on the way forward, and that’s why we’ve tabled the proposals that we have.”

He added: “In the meantime, perhaps he can clear up from his proposals whether he would continue to be able to take money as he did from Mishcon de Reya and other legal firms?”

With jeers becoming more audible from both sides in the chamber, Commons Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle intervened on proceedings, asking the PM not to ask questions of the Labour leader.

“Prime minister! Sit down! I am not going to be challenged, you may be the prime minister of this country but in this house I’m in charge,” Sir Lindsay said.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

Govt ‘needs to do better’ on sleaze

This was one of many clashes between the PM and the Speaker during this week’s PMQs session.

On another occasion, Sir Lindsay told Mr Johnson: “I don’t want to fall out about it, I’ve made it very clear – it is prime minister’s questions, it’s not for the opposition to answer your questions.

“Whether we like it or not, those are the rules of the game that we’re all into, and we play by the rules, don’t we? And we respect this house, so let’s respect the house.”

He continued: “I don’t think this has done this House any good today. I’ll be quite honest, I think it’s been ill-tempered, I think it shows the public that this House has not learnt from the other week, I need this house to gain respect, but it starts by individuals showing respect for each other.”

Meanwhile, as PMQs was ongoing, Labour’s deputy leader Angela Rayner tweeted: “Will the prime minister apologise for supporting corruption? No, no he wouldn’t – because he’s up to his neck in corruption.”

Sir Keir began PMQs by questioning the PM twice on the future of the eastern leg of HS2, following reports that the government’s long-delayed Integrated Rail Plan will show the project has been downgraded.

Mr Johnson did not confirm or deny whether the eastern leg will go ahead as planned, telling the Labour leader that what is announced tomorrow will “make life easier and better for people in the North East, in the North West, across the midlands and across the entire country”.

Sir Keir said the PM’s response was “a lot of words, but not a yes”, adding: “No wonder trust in the prime minister is at an all-time low.”

Later, Conservative Jake Berry said: “In July 2019 I was in Manchester when the PM committed to building a new line between Manchester and Leeds, a commitment reaffirmed in our manifesto and in a conference speech…were the voters of the north right to take the PM at his word?”

“Yes,” Mr Johnson replied.

Please use Chrome browser for a more accessible video player

The North ‘sick of announcements without action’

After a heated PMQs session, the PM will later face a two-hour grilling by commons select committee chairs at a hearing of the Liaison Committee on Wednesday afternoon.

He will also be put under further pressure to tackle the issue of sleaze in parliament through two Labour backbench debates based around lobbying.

Ahead of the debates, Labour published a “dossier of Conservative sleaze and corruption” containing analysis showing that £3.5bn worth of COVID contracts have been awarded to “Tory-linked firms”.

The document says 50 Conservative MPs have earned £1.7m in consultancy fees this year alone, with Ms Rayner stating: “The Owen Paterson scandal is the just tip of the Conservative corruption iceberg.”

 Sky News

© Sky News 2020

Tagged as